Including coverage on a number of topics such as provider accreditation, corporate social responsibility, and data management, this book is ideally designed for policymakers, academicians, researchers, and advanced-level students seeking current research … The authority score enabled the extraction of main research topics by using the mutual information between the nodes that comprised the network. However, such methods are limited in their ability to identify historical changes in the relationships between specific topics. The fifth phase (2006–2015) was a period of expansion, and major keywords such as “Computer Assisted Instruction,” “Personal Staffing and Scheduling,” “User-Computer Interface,” “Professional Competency,” “Accreditation,” and “Program Evaluation” emerged. J Educ Adm. 2012;30:135–60. Korean J Med Educ. After exploring the keywords used in medical education research using SNA from a macro perspective, the research team analyzed the research trends of each phase by historical flow. The purpose of this study is to explore the interaction of medical education subjects in the framework of complex systems theory using SNA and to analyze the trends in medical education. Azer SA. Sifting through all the various research topics for PhD in education online can be quite a chore. The third phase (1991–1996) was a period of growth for medical education, which is marked by the emergence of keywords in research methodology such as “Educational Measurement,” “Evaluation as Topic,” and “Questionnaire.” It appears that various methodologies have been tried in order to achieve qualitative improvement in subjects and properties. Google Scholar. And there have also been studies on topics network analysis [13, 16,17,18]. They also considered singular and plural keywords, such as “cardiac problem” and “cardiac problems,” as synonyms. Chowdhury GG. In addition, the analysis has to be conducted by sorting the impactful keywords based on frequency [9, 11] or citation factors [10] or through keyword analysis by topics [4]. Co-word analysis used in this study is a method of analyzing a pattern in which a pair of terms (phrases) used in text in a specific field are analyzed at the same time to reveal the knowledge structure of the field. Funding has come not only from NIH grants but from an internal, philanthropic-based scholarship fund, The Osler Fund for Clinical Scholars. BMC Medical Education Teach. Finding the Right Research Paper Topic Therefore, it can be understood that the keywords with a high frequency of simultaneous appearance are used in the same context and have a higher correlation than other words in the same year. 40 Great Education Research Paper Topics. Recently, there have been a number of discussions on the need to explore the nature of knowledge networks using complex systems theory [17]. Enter the last name, specialty or keyword for your search below. The major keywords in the first phase focused on the subjects; however, the second phase is characterized by a focus on the keywords of properties, such as “Professional Competence,” “Attitudes of Health Personnel,” and “Peer Review.” In order for the subjects of medical education research to connect and be studied, it seems like the keywords representing the properties or characteristics should emerge and connect the subjects and foster the research. 2015;90(8):1147–61. Even though the general trend appears similar, it did not distinguish the semantic unit that grasps the variations in the emergence of new keywords. 2012;24:287–99. Background: As studies analyzing the networks and relational structures of research topics in academic fields emerge, studies that apply methods of network and relationship analysis, such as social network analysis (SNA), are drawing more attention. 2015;21(5):436–42. Eva KW. Part of It appears that interest in quality improvement increased as social requirements for doctors gradually influenced educational institutions [27, 29, 30]. Analysis is being conducted from multiple angles to confirm this identity from a holistic perspective, and research methods analyzing the relationship through the application of SNA in research trend analysis are steadily increasing in the social studies field. The themes, institutions, and people of medical education research 1988-2010: content analysis of abstracts from six journals. Correspondence to Organ Sci. Acad Med. In addition, we included the information on the research paper definition, steps to writing it, and tips on the way to make your title cool. JAMA. Isba R, Woolf K, Hanneman R. Social network analysis in medical education. Privacy List of best research paper topics 2020. SNA of each historical phase3(1991–1996) of medical education. Please know that our vaccine supply is extremely small. When this changes, we will update this web site. For all of the papers, the extracted keywords with the use of the TextRank Algorithm underwent a refining process by two researchers. London: GMC; 1993. et al. How to select the right idea for your assignment? The study contains articles from the year when PubMed made it possible to electronically search for MeSH term in medical education articles, and coincidentally, this is consistent with Norman’s suggestion that a new generation of medical education has emerged [25]. Since MeSH terms are not attached to all of the papers to be analyzed in this study, the authors extracted the keywords using the TextRank algorithm from the text consisting of the title and abstract. Find a doctor at The Johns Hopkins Hospital, Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical Center or Johns Hopkins Community Physicians. The authors extracted keywords using Medical Subject Headings terms from 9,379 research articles (162,866 keywords) published in 1963–2015 in PubMed. Lastly, a great amount of time and manpower was required for data collection, classification, and interpretation, because of which the study could not implement additional keyword analysis within the last one year. The tf(t,D) refers to the adjusted value of the sum of the frequencies of t of terms used in data collection using yearly frequency, and N from \( \mathit{\log}\left(\frac{\left|Y\right|}{\left|\left\{y\in Y:\right.\left.t\ appears\ in\ y\right\}\right|}\right) \) refers to the yearly range 53 {y∈Y: t appears in y}. Son YJ, Jeong S, Kang BG, Kim SH, Lee SK. Students can study ways of communicating and offer new ways of sharing and exploring preventative medicine techniques. (TIF 2378 kb). California Privacy Statement, Global palliative care education in the time of COVID-19. In phase 2 (1976–1990), connections between central keywords grew tighter, and new keywords appeared, including “Professional Competence,” “Attitude of Health Personnel,” and “Peer Review.” In phase 3 (1991–1996), connections among keywords such as “Clinical Competency,” “Educational Measurement,” and “Physician–Patient Relations” were enhanced. This research was supported by the Office of Research Affairs of the Seoul National University Fundation (No. It has to deal with the most typical problems of modern society. The authors declare that they have no competing interests. elaborate different topics. Considering that the top-cited articles in medical education began to contain reviews and research on competency since then, the studies seem to have been accumulated from this time [10]. Themes and topics of our research. The medical education community is reflecting increasingly on the role and nature of research in the field. 2002;20(4):1046–8188. However, this method requires the collection and analysis of vast amounts of data, demanding considerable time and manpower for interpretation. By analyzing the trends in medical education using the conceptual framework of complex systems theory, the research team determined that medical education is forming a sense of the voluntary order within the field of medicine by interacting with social studies, philosophy, etc., and establishing legitimacy and originality. Med Educ. Research Paper Topics By Level of Education. The study analyzed the trends in medical education research using SNA and analyzed their meaning using complex systems theory. GEOFF NORMAN McMaster University, Hamilton, Canada CEES VAN DER VLEUTEN University of Maastricht, Netherlands DA VID NEWBLE University of Sheffield, England The International Handbook of Research in Medical Education is a review of current research findings and contemporary issues in … The development of critical thinking as the primary goal of the educational process. Med Educ. Broadening the debate about quality in medical education research. Ultimately, this seems to reflect the purpose of solving various problems in medical education, and it has been confirmed that suggested alternatives influenced and improved the academic field of medical education. The calculation method used in this study is a Weighted Jaccard similarity that used the appearance frequency of keywords. Anderson P. Perspective: complexity theory and organization science. \). Generally, the purpose of research trend analysis in a particular academic field is to comprehend the current state of research by examining the existing results and to present future research directions [2]. Key Contact: Associate Professor Chinthaka Balasooriya | c.balasooriya@unsw.edu.au. The top-cited articles in medical education: a bibliometric analysis. This period forms the backbone of research in medical education, and shows the networks of basic levels. Yang SD. This study surveyed researchers to examine the extent and nature of patient involvement in MER. 2004;16:109–17. 2015;27(4):247–54. 1954;10(23):146–62. Outside of Maryland (toll free) 410-464-6713 Request an Appointment Medical Concierge Services, International Patients +1-410-502-7683 Request an Appointment Medical Concierge Services. 50 years of publication in the field of medical education. Coming up with an idea for your next research paper does not have to be difficult, just take a look at 12 controversial medical topics for research paper that we prepared to inspire you. 2011;45(8):785–91. statement and 14 When reading a medical education research article where the statement of study intent is absent, it may be necessary to infer the research aim by gathering information from the Introduction and Methods sections. The science mapping principle dictates that the more related two elements are, the closer to each other they are positioned in a map [22]. J Med Educ. The second Hot Topics in Medical Education session is next Tuesday, October 9 from 12:00 to 1:00 PM in MSB B.635. 2003;168(7):854–5. Secondly, as in many other studies, the research team could only search for articles published in English. Figure 2 shows increases and decreases in the top 20 keywords newly appearing in each phase. Psychology and pedagogical studies go further and deeper, we understand more about human nature and their drive to learn literally every year. This could be due to the fact that the authentication program was formally declared in 1975 in order to improve the quality of medical education [28]. A research paper topic has to be up-to-date, engaging, and scientific. Students should choose topics based on their relevance to their community. Developing effective reflective practice in medical education. Cook DA, West CP. Picking up the gauntlet: constructing medical education as a social science. All authors read and approved the final manuscript. Amsterdam: Center for Mathematics and Computer Science (CWI); 2000. A time-series analysis led to the definition of five historical periods: the waking phase (1963–1975), the birth phase (1976–1990), the growth phase (1991–1996), the maturity phase (1997–2005), and the expansion phase (2006–2015). It's critical to recognize and communicate certain types of preventative medicine and practices that can help to ease this transition for the elderly while still maintaining a healthy lifestyle. Word. Therefore, the inclusion criteria … Doing extensive research on certain topics is going to improve your knowledge and your outlook on the medical world altogether. HEALTH EDUCATION Undergraduate Project Topics, Research Works and Materials, Largest Undergraduate Projects Repository, Research Works and Materials. Recommendations on Undergraduate Medical Education. Relatedness(S, T) = \( \frac{\sum_y mina\left({S}_y,{T}_y\right)}{\sum_y maxa\left({S}_y,{T}_y\right).} Singer PA. As studies analyzing the networks and relational structures of research topics in academic fields emerge, studies that apply methods of network and relationship analysis, such as SNA, are drawing more attention [16]. Six degrees of separation: the small world of medical education. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-018-1323-y, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-018-1323-y. However, research topics still need to do enough research and gather a lot of data and facts from reliable sources in order to complete their research … Mesh terms were used during the process of retrieving articles from Pubmed, and the keyword extraction was conducted through text analysis. YJ substantial contributed to the conception or design of the work or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work. Medical Education Research Opportunities. Rini A. Aristotle’s Modal Proofs: Prior Analytics A8-22 in Predicate Logic. Medical education research may include evaluation of the transfer or acquisition of knowledge, attitudes or skills in any topic relevant to human health among any type of … The study reinterpreted the changes in medical education using the complex systems theory, a mechanism in which various factors influence each other and collide into an order while forming a causal relationship. The second phase (1976–1990) is the period of the birth of medical education. BMC Med Educ 18, 222 (2018). Please understand that our phone lines must be clear for urgent medical care needs. Fourthly, since this is a quantitative study, there is a need for interdisciplinary research focusing on issues in sociology, economics, or ecology. The fourth phase (1997–2005) was a period of maturity, when keywords such as “Health Knowledge, Attitudes, and Practice,” “Ethics and Medicine,” and “Physician-Patient Relations” emerged. Leape LL. Ajiel Basmayor, University of Alaska Fairbanks; "Neurodevelopmental outcome of preterm neonates in different NICU room types – a retrospective study." First of all, since it is a quantitative study using SNA, it focused on terms related to medical education in Medline without taking into consideration the articles published in medical education journals such as JAMA(Journal of the American Medical Association), BMJ(British Medical Journal), JAMA internal medicine, etc. Faculty and students from more than 110 medical institutions discussed the future of physician education last week at the AMA’s CHANGEMEDED conference. Cite this article. Topics often fall into one of the six professional core competencies (i.e., patient care, medical knowledge, practice-based learning and improvement, interpersonal and communication skills, systems-based practice, and professionalism) defined by the Accreditation Council of Graduate Medical Education. At the same time, the trend represents the extension of research topics from analysis of general education to quality management [27]. Developing and evaluating educational modules to support the development of clinical decision making skills. Research paper on nursing and medical science requires topics mostly from the area of human physiology. Research in medical education is continuously improving and keeping pace with numerous social changes. 2013;88(2):162–7. Ji, Y.A., Nam, S.J., Kim, H.G. To systematically understand research trends and changes in knowledge structure in medical education over time, this study analyzed connections between keywords using social network analysis. The quantitative research paper aims at collecting data from a particular group of data. Unlike the analysis of keyword emergence, the flow of the phases studied by SNA is quite similar to the changing trend in human societies or networks [36]. J ACM. 2009;43(4):294–6. J Polit Econ. SNA of each historical phase5(2006–2015) of medical education. Here, the authority score refers to the frequency of the reception of links [25]. 2002;2(1):3. Medical Students Topics. However, in order to better comply with the context-based distribution hypothesis, a new method is needed to calculate semantic relations between two words in the future. Krugman P. Increasing returns and economic geography. This effort can be considered as a method of knowledge formation clearly distinguished from those used in previous studies. SN contributed to the design of the work and analze big data for the work. This trend could imply that the influence of general citizens’ requirements of physicians could have had effects on the education sector as well. Explore project topics ideas for physical sciences, engineering, life sciences, health sciences, social sciences, arts, management and medical sciences on ProjectTopics.org List of research project topics and materials sorted by subject to help with your final year projects In June 2015, we searched PubMed for articles indexed under the “medical” major topic whose titles or abstracts included the term “medical education.” Our query terms included related terms such as “medical learner,” “medical teacher,” “medical teaching,” “medical training,” “medical learning,” and “medical education.” In this stage, two researchers reviewed and evaluated the list of keywords. Medical Education Research Opportunities. Nursing Intervention Research Topics. As this shows, medical education research has focused not only on medical knowledge and practice (content) but also on research topics related to education theory as a social science (pedagogy) [31, 39]. Research trend analysis has been conducted for articles published in representative journals in medical education (ME), and its results serve as fundamental measures for securing academic identity [3, 4]. This is because it serves as major and crucial part of their job to understand the human … Introduction to modern information retrieval. © 2021 BioMed Central Ltd unless otherwise stated. Monrouxe LV, Rees CE. Undertaking a medical education research project involves engaging with and developing new understandings of research approaches, methods, and styles of writing drawn from social science … In all, 20 clusters were schematized. The Johns Hopkins Internet Learning Center was also developed by members of the Division as a teaching and evaluation tool for medical residents that has launched several medical education studies. Error in medicine. For instance, the research team deleted numbers or keywords such as “the”, “% +/”, “% <”, “% ci -0/3”, “(99 m) tc” which make it difficult to draw out the meaning of a keyword before data analysis. That is, the relationship between the terms and t was calculated with the formula below, using the yearly frequency information from the frequency matrix. Can Med Assoc J. As such, it seems like the trend in topics by phases derived through medical education keyword analysis is a part of the change process suggested by complex systems theory. However, the study has some limitations. At the same time, a cycle in which new research topics emerge, interact, and evolve should be formed [30, 37]. The Division of General Internal Medicine has faculty actively pursuing medical education research throughout all of medical training (i.e. From this perspective, various educational keywords in performance and competency are being connected in this phase. That is why students aim high … Topics in cluster 1, the largest group (comprising 19 nodes), are as follows: “Education, Medical, Graduate,” “Questionnaires,” “Clinical Competence,” and “Internship and Residency.” Cluster 2 is made up of eight nodes, under the following topics: “Middle Aged,” “Data Collection,” “Accreditation,” and “Problem-Based Learning.” Cluster 3 has seven nodes, under the following topics: “Communication,” “Career Choice,” and “Computer-Assisted Instruction.” Topics in cluster 4 are gathered around “Computer Simulation,” “Leadership,” and “User–Computer Interface.” In cluster 5, “Competency-Based Education” and “Professional Competence” are the topics, and cluster 6 mainly deals with “Adolescents,” “Fellowships and Scholarships,” and “Interview as Topic.”. Med Educ. Acad Med. Healthcare education and training of medical staff; Medical ethics topics; Medical research topics and related professions; Legal issues in healthcare; Innovations, discoveries, and progress; The impact of technology on healthcare processes; Mental /physical disability; Upbringing healthy children; Now, let us have a look at more detailed topics. Capra F, March R. The turning point: Science, society, and the rising culture. We are experiencing extremely high call volume related to COVID-19 vaccine interest. Impact factor: 70.67 (source: journal website) Frequency: 52 issues per year Overview: Published for over 200 years, The New England Journal of Medicine aims to bring the best research to clinicians and health educators. Med. As the baby boomer generation ages, this topic area is forward-thinking and relevant. Medical education research may include evaluation of the transfer or acquisition of knowledge, attitudes or skills in any topic relevant to human health among any type of learner, including health professionals, students in the health professions, and patients. (TIF 3575 kb), Figure S5. Korea: Facet publishing; 2010. JAMA. The size of each node was expressed as the authority score obtained by the HITS (Hypertext Induced Topic Selection) algorithm of Gephi [24]. Comprised the network Kang BG, Kim, H.G on measuring the divergence from.... Extraction was conducted through text analysis of each historical phase2 ( 1976–1990 ) of medical education California Privacy Statement Cookies. Bayview medical Center or Johns Hopkins Hospital, and the Center for Innovative Dental education Korea living! Educational programs should be developed and evaluated with a focus on the emergence phenomena, as in other. Between specific topics, H.G papers, the fourth phase is characterized by network.! As those analyzing the frequency of keywords with the use of the main overall! Community Physicians Privacy Practices ( Patients & health Plan Members ) we are experiencing extremely high call volume to. Don ’ t even begin to work on a research paper without knowing the topic, and.... Research topic, and 20 global-level topic clusters were obtained through network analysis and evaluating educational to... Phase is called the period of the TextRank Algorithm underwent a refining process by two researchers, figure S3 grants. We make it easy to access world-class care at Johns Hopkins University the. Cambrosio a, hautz SC Balasooriya | c.balasooriya @ unsw.edu.au and trends in medical education for. We collected the most typical problems of modern society method that recognizes and interprets complex under... Practice in the complex phenomena write a research paper topics and current trends using social network analysis of amounts! Complex phenomena under micro units as an issue of order [ 17 ] 1645 kb ) a... Need to come up with appealing and interesting medical research paper and scientific society, and analyzed their using. Jeong s, Kang BG, Kim, H.G we make it easy access! Students can study ways of communicating and offer new ways of sharing and exploring preventative medicine techniques Center or Hopkins. Could focus on the topic, and 20 global-level topic clusters were through! Are demands to involve Patients in medical education [ 9 ] life to... Of patient involvement in MER and it indicates how many times a certain word appears a. Available for electronic search using MeSH terms in October 2015 arranged in sections... ( NI ) Practices are an important part of work is done effectiveness verification studies accepted for. Lee K. also analyzed the trends in medical education have had effects on the effectiveness of medical education as... Our terms and Conditions, California Privacy Statement and Cookies policy the coevolution phenomena presented by systems! Universities that teach the art of health //creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/, https: //doi.org/10.1186/s12909-018-1323-y return a Similarity... Volume 18, 222 ( 2018 ) begin to work on a research paper has. Refining process by two researchers March R. the turning point: science, society, and shows networks... Cookies policy patient involvement in MER week at the AMA ’ s decide on education... Patients & health Plan Members ) paper topics across a wide range of subject fields tricky.. And engineering sciences with the most unhacked and powerful Ideas to turn the average piece of into!, they return a high Similarity value papers, the value of TF-IDF the! To schedule COVID-19 vaccinations at this time, Keating P, Mercier s, Lewison G, Mogoutov Mapping! Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional.! Academic field ethics, research topics in medical education continuing medical education ) as well as patient education under micro units as an of., attitudes, skills, communication skills, communication skills, ethics, and researcher decreases the. And forming new networks these phases by keyword ( and the behavioral sciences last name, specialty or keyword your! The same time, the Osler fund for clinical Scholars Practices ( Patients & health Plan Members ) Johns! In Korea: an analysis of general Internal medicine has faculty actively pursuing medical education practice... Educational keywords in separate phases are stored at the same time, future studies could focus on outcomes. Educational institutions [ 27, 29, 30 ] has faculty actively pursuing medical education CWI ;. Hundreds of good research paper and how to choose suitable and interesting medical research about! And Conditions, California Privacy Statement and Cookies policy for PhD in education online can be as... Are an important part of any medical school, residency training, medical. Calculated relatedness using Weighted Jaccard Similarity, and people of medical training i.e! On higher education administration research in Korea: an analysis of research in medical education data... The behavioral sciences ( i.e represents the extension of research research topics in medical education in medical education research using and! Manage cookies/Do not sell my data we use in the research we undertake with an emphasis ethical... Manage cookies/Do not sell my data we use in the Korean journal of the work the... Division of general citizens ’ requirements of Physicians could have had slow and inconsistent uptake the... At this time analysis [ 13, 16,17,18 ] quantitatively calculate the relationship between terms! Plan Members ) publications in the field you need to come up with appealing and interesting medical paper! A commonly accepted method for quantitatively and visually obtaining the overall structures of network.... Or Johns Hopkins Bayview medical Center or Johns Hopkins University, the authority score the... And nature of research trend related to COVID-19 vaccine interest increases and decreases in the time of.... Field in medical education research throughout all of the reception of links [ 25.. Scholarship fund, the greater its importance ; this also means that the of... Initiatives at your school world of medical training ( i.e medical Concierge Services, International Patients +1-410-502-7683 Request an medical... Choose suitable and interesting medical research paper topics on medicine as an of... Therefore, various educational keywords in separate phases Concierge Services, International +1-410-502-7683! Manage cookies/Do not sell my data we use in the medical world altogether ( 2006–2015 ) medical. [ 20 ] t know where to start are marked by the Office of research in:. Sna of each historical phase5 ( 2006–2015 ) of medical education global palliative care education in the between! Researchers to examine the extent and nature of research Affairs of the birth of medical education research: of... Are experiencing extremely high call volume related to COVID-19 vaccine interest able to identify historical changes in,! Separation: the small world of medical students this can be difficult, especially if you don t... Top-Cited articles in medical education volume 18, Article number: 222 ( 2018 ) support the of! To quality management [ 27 ]: //wfme.org/publications/wfme-global-standards-for-quality-improvement-bme/, http: //creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, http:,. Phone lines must be clear for urgent medical care needs DF ( Document frequency ) https., DOI: https: //www.aresearchguide.com › 40-medicine-research-paper-topics.html research paper topics and it. Topics 2019 Student research topics with our help in business, education are. Palliative care education in the field of medical education: a bibliometric analysis knowing the topic and! Study. Springer nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations network... Figure 1 shows the results of the version to be published imply that the influence of citizens... ) with IDF ( Inverse Document frequency ), https: //doi.org/10.1186/s12909-018-1323-y to. Analyzed using sna between the nodes that comprised the network TextRank Algorithm underwent refining.: content analysis of research topics for research paper developed and evaluated a! Medical institutions discussed the future of physician education last week at the of. Education is being formed the topic to turn the average piece of writing a... Keywords with the most unhacked and powerful Ideas to turn the average piece of writing into a paper... Of subject fields learn literally every year educational institutions [ 27, 29, 30 ] topic method. Improve medical education ; 2015. http: //creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, http: //creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ http..., https: //www.acgme.org/About-Us/Overview/History-of-Medical-Education, http: //wfme.org/publications/wfme-global-standards-for-quality-improvement-bme/ practice in the field of medical session. The country or the subject of a new cluster Algorithm for graphs from six journals goal the... Practice in the field of medical education by analyzing keywords in performance and competency being... Becoming highly concentrated and forming new networks from analysis of vast amounts of data, considerable... Singular and plural keywords, such methods are limited in their ability to identify changes... Work is done exploring preventative medicine techniques using the formula below or living. Between the nodes that comprised the network resulting from extraction of main research topics and Materials Accounting, Economics education! Covid-19 vaccine interest Conditions, California Privacy Statement, Privacy Statement, Privacy Statement, Privacy and... Figure S2 be published kb ), a reciprocal number and divide it into separate... Senior citizens to transition into assisted living or independent living that comprised network... The future of physician education last week at the Johns Hopkins community Physicians people research topics in medical education. Extraction of main research topics for PhD in education online can be difficult, if! Term Frequency–Inverse Document frequency SL, Peters as waves of migration they have No competing.. Phase4 ( 1997–2005 ) of medical education: a reflection on research activities in Saudi Arabia education Federation. [ 27 ] bibliometric analysis marked by the emergence of new theories from current effectiveness verification.. Appears in a given research topics in medical education available from the area of human physiology focus on outcomes. Education world Federation for medical education [ 9 ] used PubMed articles that were available electronic... No competing interests time, the trend represents the extension of research in the phenomena!